Brave enough to meet the ghost's first headline?
Your mission
The First Telling Reveal
Find the oldest newspaper article about your chosen ghost story, then read it aloud to your crew at the spot at dusk. Before you read, everyone guesses one detail the original will leave out.
Bonus challenge: Give your ghost a silly nickname based on what the first article really said, and award it to the friend whose guess was closest.
Grab a friend and pick a ghost story people in your town still whisper about. Then play detective at the library and hunt down the very first time a newspaper printed it. The best part comes at dusk: you read that old article out loud, right where it happened.
Somewhere in your town there's a story everyone half-knows: the lady on the bridge, the lights in the old mill, the footsteps on the inn stairs. But who told it first, and what did they actually say? You'll pick one legend, follow its trail through old newspapers at the library, then stand on the spot as the sky goes dim. Librarians love this kind of question, so you won't be hunting alone. Then comes the big reveal.
Ghost stories grow every time someone retells them. A headless rider might start life as a short note about a strange noise on a farm road. Finding that first version feels like catching the story in its pajamas. And reading it aloud where it happened, as the light fades, gives everyone goosebumps you'll be laughing about all week.
Top gear to make this quest great.
Pull it off
It lights your path back once dusk turns to dark.
Many microfilm readers let you save old pages straight onto it for free.
A warm cocoa makes standing at a chilly spooky spot much cozier.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Prices may change.
Good news: the hardest part of detective work is picking which ghost to chase. Essentials: a library card, the name of one local ghost story, and a rough idea of where it happened. Call or check your library's website to ask which old newspapers they keep, either on microfilm (tiny photos of old pages on film reels) or online. Handy extras: a flashlight for the walk back, a USB flash drive to save archive pages, and a warm drink for the dusk visit. Make sure the spot is public and open at dusk.
Which story gives you the best shivers? Ask friends, family or a local history page for town legends, then pick one with a real place attached, like a bridge, a crossroads or an old hotel. Jot nothing down yet. Just agree on the ghost and the spot together.
Time to open the case files. Head to the library's reference or local history desk and tell them which ghost you're chasing. Ask which old local papers they have and how to search them. Librarians often know the town legends already and may point you to the perfect reel or database.
Now the real detective work starts. Search the place name with words like ghost, haunted, strange or apparition, and go back one decade at a time. When you spot a mention, keep going earlier until the trail stops. That oldest article is your treasure. Save it to a little USB flash drive that plugs into a library computer at one end and a phone at the other, then print a copy too.
Here's the twist. Before anyone reads the full article, each person guesses one spooky detail from today's version that the original will leave out. Maybe the ghost had no name back then, or the scream was really just a bell. Keep your guesses secret until the dusk visit.
This is the moment. Arrive about fifteen minutes before sunset and stand where the story says it happened. Bring a warm treat, like cocoa or soup in an insulated food jar that keeps it hot for up to seven hours. Once the light starts to fade, say your guesses out loud, then read the original article in your best storyteller voice. Who guessed right? Did the place feel different once you heard the real words?
Case solved, detectives. Before you head home, award the ghost its new nickname and crown the best guesser. Walk back with your flashlight on, swapping theories about how the story grew so wild. Glance at its little battery screen before you leave the house so you know it's charged for the walk back. Hand the printed article to whoever loves the legend most.
You traced a town legend back to its very first telling and read it where it all began. Now challenge a friend to pick a different ghost and race you to its first headline.
You bring the curiosity. We've found the tools.
Pull it off
It lights your path back once dusk turns to dark.
Many microfilm readers let you save old pages straight onto it for free.
A small plug-in drive for saving files.
Get on Amazon · $57.65 — USB flash drivewhat to look for & our pick →
A warm cocoa makes standing at a chilly spooky spot much cozier.
A bottle that keeps drinks hot.
Get on Amazon · $22.99 — Insulated thermoswhat to look for & our pick →RELATED GEAR GUIDE
Tabletop RPG Starter Kit: 10 Picks That Earn Their Table Space
Practical picks, real prices · Social & Community
As an Amazon Associate, IRL Sidequests earns from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Prices and availability are subject to change. The price shown at checkout on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.
Where this one naturally leads next.
Grab a clipboard. The ghosts are waiting for their reviews.
Grab your favorite people and a printed scorecard, then walk your neighborhood after dark judging every Halloween display you pass. Who has the creepiest skeleton? The best fog machine? At the end, your crew picks a winner and sneaks a handmade Best in Street award onto their doorstep.
Those faded paint ads on brick walls are disappearing faster than you think—here's how to find and preserve them before they're gone.
Hunt down fading painted advertisements on old brick buildings and create a visual archive of your neighborhood's commercial history.
Those faded paint ads on brick walls? They're time capsules worth thousands in stories.
Hunt down faded vintage advertisements painted on brick buildings and learn to read the stories hidden in your city's walls.
Not this one?
Tell the generator how much time you have, who you're with, and your mood — it picks from 500+ quests like this one.
Try the real life side quest generatorOr browse the full list of real-life side quest ideas or side quests to do with friends.