Every chipped mug deserves a heroic past.
Your mission
The Tall Tale Gift Swap
Buy your secret person a thrift-shop gift for $10 or less, invent its made-up history, and read that story aloud as they unwrap it. Then everyone votes for the best backstory.
Bonus challenge: Before the vote, the receiver adds one new chapter to their gift's story on the spot.
Gather your friends for a Secret Santa with a twist. Everyone gets $10 and one thrift shop to buy a gift. Then each giver tells the wildest made-up history of what's inside. That ceramic frog? It once guarded a pirate's lighthouse.
Picture the gift pile: lumpy, mysterious and bought for pocket change. When each one gets unwrapped, the giver stands up and tells the room exactly where it came from. Spoiler: it's all made up, and it's glorious. You'll draw names, hunt a thrift shop with a $10 cap, invent a backstory, then gather for the big reveal. You don't need to be funny or a great storyteller. A silly name and one ridiculous detail are plenty. Your mission is waiting below.
A $10 gift from a thrift shop can be the best present of the season, because it comes with a story somebody invented just for you. Your friends will laugh at the tale, then keep that odd little candle holder for years. The cheapest gift on the table often gets the loudest cheer.
Top gear to make this quest great.
Pull it off
It hides your thrift treasure until the big story moment.
Get on Amazon · $8.99 — Wrapping paper
Odd-shaped gifts slip right in, no wrapping wrestle required.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Prices may change.
If you can wrap a lumpy object, you're ready. Essentials: a hat or bowl to draw names from, a $10 bill (or $10 on a card) for each player, wrapping paper or gift bags, and tape. Handy extras: gift tags, so givers can jot a few story notes on the back; a Santa hat, which makes the storyteller feel official; and a small prize for the winner. Check your thrift shop's hours and whether it takes cards before you go.
Let the secret-keeping begin! Write each player's name on a slip, fold it, and toss it in a hat or bowl. Everyone draws one and keeps it quiet. Agree on the rules out loud: $10 max, thrift shop only, and every gift gets a made-up backstory. Set the party date and time so everyone knows when to bring their tale.
Time to treasure hunt! Head to a thrift shop and wander every aisle: mugs, books, picture frames, odd figurines, scarves. Chilly walk to the shop? Open a Soupou hand warmer before you head out. It needs about 15 to 30 minutes in the air to warm up, then keeps your pockets cozy for hours while you dig. Look for something that makes you smile or wonder where it's been. What would make your person laugh? Keep your total at $10 or under, tax included if your group agrees.
Now give your gift a life story. Who owned it first? What did it survive? Was it a queen's soup ladle, or a lucky charm for a space mission? Pick a name for the object, add one ridiculous detail and one dramatic moment. Aim for a story that takes about a minute to read aloud.
Make it look intriguing! Wrap your gift so nobody can guess its shape, or tuck it deep in a gift bag with tissue. A roll like the RUSPEPA gold foil Christmas tree paper is 17 inches wide and made to resist tearing, so you can bunch it around a lumpy figurine or a pointy frame without it ripping. Put the receiver's name on the outside and your story notes safely in your pocket. A strange shiny lump builds wonderful suspense at the party.
Here comes the main event! Gather in a circle with snacks. One at a time, a giver hands over their gift and starts reading the backstory while the receiver unwraps it. Gasp at the twists. Cheer for the brave ceramic owl. Once every story is told, everyone votes for the best tale with a quick show of hands.
Crown your storytellers! Give the winner the prize, then hand out bonus titles like Most Dramatic Origin, Best Bargain and Gift Most Likely to Be Haunted. A photo booth prop set makes it extra silly: it comes with surprise party hats like a crown or a captain's hat, plus a hand pump for the inflatable props, so every winner gets dressed up for their moment. Line up all the gifts together for a group picture of your strange new treasures, and ask who wants to host next year.
You turned $10 and a pile of thrift finds into a night of legendary stories. Before everyone heads home, pick next year's host and dare them to top the winning tale.
You bring the curiosity. We've found the tools.
Pull it off
It hides your thrift treasure until the big story moment.
Get on Amazon · $8.99 — Wrapping paperwhat to look for & our pick →
Odd-shaped gifts slip right in, no wrapping wrestle required.
Reusable paper gift bags with tissue paper.
Get on Amazon · $23.99 — Gift bags with tissuewhat to look for & our pick →
Names go on the front and your story clues go on the back.
Small paper tags with strings.
Get on Amazon · $14.99 — Gift tagswhat to look for & our pick →
Whoever wears it holds the stage for their tale.
A classic red and white felt hat.
Get on Amazon · $57.99 — Santa hatwhat to look for & our pick →RELATED GEAR GUIDE
Tabletop RPG Starter Kit: 10 Picks That Earn Their Table Space
Practical picks, real prices · Social & Community
As an Amazon Associate, IRL Sidequests earns from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Prices and availability are subject to change. The price shown at checkout on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.
Hand-selected quests our team thinks you'll love
Your people are out there, probably within three miles of your house.
Stop scrolling, start connecting. Strategic field guide to finding genuine communities through skill-sharing, interest groups, and face-to-face meetups.
That cracked sidewalk planter doesn't need to stay dead—fill it with wildflowers at 2AM and watch neighbors smile for months.
Learn guerrilla gardening tactics to green up forgotten urban corners with native plants, seed bombs, and nighttime planting missions.
Getting better at talking is weirdly fun with friends
Round up six friends, drag some chairs into a circle in your yard, and spend 90 minutes getting genuinely better at talking to people. One skill, eight-minute pair rounds, a soft chime to switch partners, and a lot more laughing than you'd expect.
Not this one?
Tell the generator how much time you have, who you're with, and your mood — it picks from 500+ quests like this one.
Try the real life side quest generatorOr browse the full list of real-life side quest ideas or side quests to do with friends.
